Reader Response:
I think that this story ties in very strongly of our study of biodiversity and
biomes. This story is particularly interesting because these animals do not
ordinarily interact with one another, and because it follows the narrative of
the lives of these two animals, it invokes an emotional response. The reader
begins to personify the two animals and their blossoming “friendship”. This
story weaves together factual science information and tells the story of an
unlikely friendship, which appeals to students in the middle grade levels.
Evaluator Response:
I think the strengths of this book for classroom use lie in the fact that this
in a non-fiction book that tells a detailed, scientific story about animal
adaptation. The book is lengthy and contains some rather complex details about
the original conditions Owen was found in after a Tsunami in Kenya, how the
Conservancy brought Owen into livable conditions, and how the two animals
adapted to one another for protection and affection. This is not the typical
children’s picture book that avoids scientifically dense bits of information
for the sake of creating a narrative. This book seamlessly weaves the two
together.
Teacher Response:
If there was a student in my class that really enjoyed reading this story, I
would direct that student to other non-fiction texts about animal survival and
adaptation. One longer non-fiction novel that students might like would be Babylon’s Ark, an Incredible Rescue of the
Bagdad Zoo, by Lawrence Anthony. This story details how Iraq and U.S. troops had to work together to evacuate the
zoo in the heart of Bagdad after the Iraq War began.
For
students who might be at a lower reading level, I would recommend The Bravest Dog Ever, the True Story of
Balto, by Natalie Sandiford. This 48 page book is written like a novel ,
but is the true story of a dog who was the leader of a bobsled team in one of
the worst snow storms to hit Alaska in decades. Students who enjoy learning
about animals and survival instincts will devour this book.
Literacy Coach
Response: As a literacy coach recommending teachers use this text in your
classroom, I would have teachers use it after teaching the Grassland and
Tropical Grassland biome. If students have spent some time exploring this biome
in particular, as a class or as an individual project, this text would give
teachers a way to invest students more in the animal species of this biome.
Further, teachers could juxtapose this text after teaching about predator-prey
relationships in this biome, and explain that these two species ordinarily have
no incentive to work together, but in their unusual environmental setting in
captivity, were drawn to one another despite physiological differences.
Scholastic Books has also some teacher resources available
to go along with this book, including video clips, and interactive Owen and
Mzee games for students, that can be found at http://www.scholastic.com/browse/collection.jsp?id=669
I love this! As a science teacher, I always enjoy finding resources that help kids see science as relevant, cool and applicable. This book does that and more! I especially like how this book incorporates social/emotional tips that support how students, like this particular science lesson, may be different but are far from deficient.
ReplyDelete